Universal Translator

Showing posts with label unions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unions. Show all posts

Saturday, December 10, 2011

How About We Don’t Have a “Fair Fight”?

I may already have mentioned this, but Dean Baker has an excellent book titled The End of Loser Liberalism:  Making Markets Progressive that you can read for free here (although donations are welcomed).  It is filled chock-a-block with all kinds of economic data, analysis, and all the other number-crunching goodness one expects to find when reading Baker.

But it is the premise of the book that I think is particularly worthwhile.  Baker argues that Liberals need to start reframing, on a very basic level, the terms of the economic debate.  Right now, the conventional frame is that “Conservatives like the free market” and “Liberals like government control,” but as Baker points out this frame is a fairy story. 

By and large Conservatives don’t like the free market, what they like is monopolies and monopsonies (with themselves filling those roles), unfair information advantages over their competitors, government subsidies, and the “freedom” to defraud their customers.  (As to that last point, just think of Wall Street and the Republicans’ recent filibuster of Richard Cordray’s nomination to the CFPB; the GOP admits that Cordray is qualified for the position, they are just refusing to do anything that will empower an agency whose sole purpose is to protect the American people from being abused and defrauded by the big banks.)

Baker argues that Liberals need to do a better job of hammering this home:  that when Conservatives whine about “government intervention in the free market” what they really are whining about is anything that might prevent them from taking unfair advantage of their customers and competitors in an arena that – after all – was created and shaped by the government and all the rest of us to begin with.  What they are whining about is anything that might interfere with their efforts to cheat.

I was reminded of Baker’s book this morning whilst walking my dogs and thinking about how I’d like to see First Amendment jurisprudence change to better accommodate 21st-century society, technology and media.  Contrary to what a lot of lay people believe, the law is not a static thing.  It is organic, constantly growing and evolving as its fundamental principles are necessarily re-interpreted to better fit the constantly growing and evolving human experience.  That is why legal scholars refer to the Constitution as “a living document.”  And it is the most fundamental reason why the law – at any given time – is never perfect:  because it is always playing catch up.

The latest big step in First Amendment jurisprudence, of course, was the Citizens United decision, which proclaimed that the First Amendment prohibits the government from restricting political broadcasts sponsored by unions or corporations.  I remember that only a day or two after the decision was handed down I was listening to a discussion about it on NPR that included either current Republican frontrunner Newt Gingrich, or Karl Rove, or Grover Norquist (all three are easily confused in my long-term memory; I think it’s the Hitchcockian profile they share).  Whichever GOP flack it was, he defended the decision, arguing that it “leveled the playing field” by making more political speech available to everyone, and harped on the fact that unions had just as much unfettered right to run political ads as do corporations (e.g., management).

And this morning I suddenly realized something that is so obvious I should have picked up on it immediately the decision came down:  the Roberts Court would never have handed down Citizens United before now.  Why not?  Because it has taken this long to destroy unionized labor.

Union membership – public and private – in the United States is now at a 70-year low.  Back in the mid-50s, fully 35% of the American workforce was unionized.  Thirty years ago, 20% of all American workers still belonged to a union.  Today it’s only 11.9%, but that’s only because of public unions (which is why they have been targeted for destruction by the likes of Govs. Walker and Kasich).  Today, only 6.9% of America’s private workforce is unionized.

Do you really think the Roberts Court would have issued Citizens United back in the ‘50s, when labor unions actually had the muscle to stand up to corporate management?  Do you think the Roberts Court would have done so even thirty years ago, when labor unions might at least still have put up a decent fight?  Of course not.  But today?  Now that thirty plus years of successively gutting the labor movement has shrunk the unions until they can be kicked around with impunity?  Oh, sure, now it’s no problem for the increasingly conservative Supreme Court to issue a ruling that “levels the playing field” by letting unions and management “compete in the arena of ideas.”

Now that management is Hulk Hogan and labor is Woody Allen, now it’s okay to get government out of the way, level the playing field, and “have a fair fight.”  And may the best man win.  (Wink wink, nudge nudge.)

Because that’s always the tell, you know.  Whenever you hear someone argue against government intervention because they want “a level playing field,” “a chance to succeed on the merits,” “a fair fight,” etc. . . . pay attention to who’s making that argument.  I’ll bet you that 9 times out of 10 it’s gonna be the guy who’s the biggest, richest and meanest prick on the block, which means that he knows he can take everything for himself and screw over everybody else if only he can convince the rest of us to throw out the rules.

He doesn’t want a fair fight.  He doesn’t want to compete on the merits.  He just wants the opportunity to pillage at will.




Friday, December 2, 2011

Update: Why Labor Laws Work for Everybody

I wrote a brief post back in October about the National Labor Relations Board lawsuit against Boeing for illegally moving production of its 787 Dreamliner from unionized Washington state to right-to-work state South Carolina in retaliation for Boeing's workers exercising their labor rights. 

The NLRB didn’t really have much choice in the matter, given that Boeing’s CEO pretty much had publicly declared that Boeing made its relocation decision in order to punish its workers for striking – which is flat-out illegal.  But, of course, the NLRB’s lawsuit became a cause celebre for the GOP presidential candidates, who thundered against this “government interference” with private enterprise, and the Republican-led House passed a bill to take away the NLRB’s power to enforce labor laws that regulate management.  (Presumably the NLRB would still retain the power to enforce the labor laws that regulate workers.)

But yesterday Boeing and its labor unions announced that they had reached a mutually satisfactory deal resolving this dispute.  Essentially, Boeing agreed to build its 737 Max aircraft in Washington, in exchange for the union dropping its opposition to Boeing assembling some 787 Dreamliners in non-union South Carolina.  If union members ratify the deal it will “alleviate the threat of strikes” and “pave the way for a planned jump in production by the aerospace giant.”  The union would also ask that the NLRB withdraw its complaint against Boeing.

This sounds like a win/win solution to me:  the unions and Washington state get to keep jobs and work in Washington, management gets to avoid labor strikes and a costly lawsuit, and South Carolina gets a new aircraft production facility.  Hooray!  Everybody wins!  (Except, perhaps, the non-union employees in South Carolina who will get paid less than their organized counterparts in Washington but - you know what? - those workers in South Carolina should unionize.  Oh wait . . . in a right-to-work state, they pretty much can't.  Bummer.)

But it should be stressed that one of the reasons a solution like this could be hammered out – maybe even the only reason a solution like this could be hammered out – is because the National Labor Relations Board still exists and still is charged with enforcing US labor laws, which are still on the books for very good reasons.  I don’t think there should be any doubt that if the NLRB had not been around to enforce the workers’ legal rights we wouldn’t be looking at a win/win situation like the one achieved yesterday.

So, yeah . . . labor laws are good laws.  They work for the benefit of everybody, and people who continue to insist that they should all be scrapped in the name of the mythical “free market” are fools and simpletons.

Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Addendum: The End of the Stealth War

This is kind of old news, but I was reminded of something earlier today and I suddenly flashed on how it ties into what I wrote last week about the end of the stealth war, in which I argued that America’s economic elite have been made to feel so secure about their position in this country that they no longer bother to hide the fact they declared war on the rest of us some time ago.

What I was reminded of was Boeing’s decision to move the production of its 787 Dreamliner from Washington state to South Carolina.  In explaining Boeing’s decision, its CEO Jim McNerney made an extended statement about moving the 787 Dreamliner work to South Carolina due to “strikes happening every three to four years in Puget Sound.”

Now, here’s the deal:  compared to most industrially advanced countries, the United States has very weak labor protection laws.  Had Boeing simply announced its intention to relocate its Dreamliner work to South Carolina, without explanation, it probably would have gotten away with doing so.

But one thing that absolutely is illegal for management to do is to make business decisions in retaliation against workers for exercising their rights to organize, strike and collectively bargain.  McNerney's statements pretty clearly indicate that this is precisely what Boeing was doing when it decided to move the Dreamliner to South Carolina and that is why the National Labor Relations Board ended up suing Boeing:  to enforce the nation's laws and to prohibit blatantly illegal conduct.

What strikes me as significant here is that McNerney must certainly have known that he was admitting to illegal activity when he made the statement that got Boeing sued, but he either didn’t care or he didn’t think anything would come of it.  And why would he do either?  The United States has spent decades doing everything it can to benefit management at the expense of workers, until we have been brought to the point where CEOs now feel safe boasting about the illegal things they do in order to disenfranchise those workers.

But the truly sad thing is that if the Republicans sweep Congress next year, McNerney’s assessment of his and Boeing's "untouchability" may eventually turn out to be correct.  Only a few weeks ago the Republican-controlled House of Representatives approved a bill specifically designed to prohibit the NLRB from blocking Boeing’s illegal action.

And this is what the end of the stealth war against working- and middle-class Americans looks like:  management unashamedly boasting about engaging in illegal activity, and their lickspittles in Congress amending the laws so that they can get away with it.


Sunday, May 1, 2011

Ayn Rand Was Very Silly, But Conservatives Are Just Evil

"There are two novels that can change a bookish fourteen-year old's life:
The Lord of the Rings and Atlas Shrugged. One is a childish
fantasy that often engenders a lifelong obsession with its unbelievable
heroes, leading to an emotionally stunted, socially crippled adulthood,
unable to deal with the real world. The other, of course, involves orcs."

--John Rogers
Kung Fu Monkey


Johann Hari has a new column up over at the UK's The Independent that simply is a must-read. He excoriates today's Republican party for its crass insistence on promoting only the interests of the country's uberwealthy at the direct expense of the less fortunate 99% of Americans. For example, of the Ryan Budget plan he points out that "it halves taxes on the richest 1% and ends all taxes on corporate income, dividends and inheritance. It pays for it by slashing spending on food stamps, health care for the poor and elderly, and basic services. . . . Ryan says 'the reason I got involved in public service' was because he read the writings of Ayn Rand, who described the poor as 'parasites' who must 'perish', and are best summarized by the title of one of her books: The Virtue of Selfishness."

However, the vast majority of Hari's column devotes itself to Donald Trump and what it says about the modern Republican party that he is now the party's frontrunner in Presidential nominee polls. Describing Trump as "the Republican Id, finally entirely unleashed from all restraint and all reality," Hari offers up a few choice quotes from the Donald about how America should deal with the rest of the world. On Libya: "I would go in and I would take the oil . . . I would take the oil and stop this baby stuff." On Iraq: "We stay there and we take the oil. . . In the old days, when you have a war and you win, that nation's yours."

* * *

In the liberal blogosphere, which I frequent, there has been for a number of years now a good deal of focus on the new, ersatz Republican followers of Ayn Rand's writings. Alan Greenspan himself, the maestro of our current financial debacle, was one of Rand's most devoted followers -- he actually sat at her feet as a college student and was editor of one of her Objectivist publications. As a result, to this day he so objects to any government regulation of any business or financial activity that he once told Brooksley Born that he was not even in favor of prosecuting financial firms that committed fraud because that would only interfere in the market's ability to punish such firms itself. (He, Larry Summers and Bob Rubin were also instrumental in crushing Born's attempt to impose derivative regulations while she was with the CFTC; of course, given that unregulated derivatives trading is a large part - if not the largest part - of how the financial industry got into the mess it did, that decision seems in retrospect very, very stupid).

In Congress, of course, we have Rep. Paul Ryan and his plan to wage war against almost everyone in America for the benefit of his small number of rich paymasters, and we have newly elected Senator Rand Paul who makes no bones about the fact that he is an Ayn Rand devotee (although it is not true that he was named after Rand; my understanding is that his name is short for 'Randal').

And this constant reference to Ayn Rand's writings by our new Republican Overlords -- who, despite controlling only one chamber of Congress, somehow manage to decide what issues must be taken up by the government (abortion and the deficit, but not jobs or the economy) and how those issues must be framed -- and by bloviating Conservative pundits and TeeVee talking heads, has had an affect on the people who listen to such folk.

For example, about two years ago, shortly after Obama had been sworn into office and the first glimpses of Tea Party Madness were beginning to emerge among the nation's more conservative elderly, I was checking out a few books at my local library. A sizable percentage of the immediate population where I live consists of retirees. Whilst checking out my books I got into a brief conversation with the librarian, who told me that she had just started reading Atlas Shrugged as part of a local book club. She told me she thought it was important that as many people as possible read Ayn Rand's opus because the book is "so relevant, given what's happening in the world today."

Now, a couple of things about this statement struck me immediately. First, I could think of nothing that was "happening in the world" right then that would make Rand's so-called philosophy more relevant than before -- that is, unless you count the fact we now have a black man sitting in the White House. Second, the library doesn't sponsor book clubs; this apparently was something she had gotten into with some unspecified number of friends, and they all had suddenly decided they needed to read Ayn Rand. Third, I couldn't just let this statement go unchallenged, because the last thing we need is people interested in reading Ayn Rand for the lessons they think they can learn from her.

So I explained to the librarian, as gently as I could, that I had read Atlas Shrugged and nearly all of Rand's writings years and years ago, back when I was in High School, and that - like a lot of people who stumble across Rand - I had enjoyed them immensely. However, after I grew up some and gained a greater appreciation of how people work in the real world, I came to see Rand's writings as fairly juvenile. I told her (as nicely as I could) that I thought they were not writings anyone should ever make the mistake of taking seriously.